Mirrored histogram of the share of in-stock listings by price per round in five-cent steps, .40 S&W above and 9mm below. The cheapest tenth of 9mm listings starts lower ($0.32 vs $0.41 a round), but the median .40 S&W listing costs $0.77 a round against $0.95 for 9mm. GunSearchEngine.com data as of Oct 18, 2026.

Blog

.40 S&W vs 9mm: What's the Difference?

Gun Search Engine·

  • handgun ammo
  • .40 S&W
  • 9mm
  • comparisons

The .40 S&W and the 9mm have been arguing at gun counters for a long time. Both are proven pistol rounds. They make different trade offs, and knowing them makes the choice easy.

Where the .40 S&W came from

Smith and Wesson and Winchester built the .40 S&W as a shorter version of the 10mm, so it would fit in a pistol frame close to 9mm size. It quickly became a police favorite, because it promised a bigger bullet without the full size and recoil of the 10mm.

How they compare

  • Bullet: the .40 S&W fires a wider, heavier bullet than the 9mm.
  • Recoil: the .40 S&W feels snappier in the same size pistol. The 9mm is softer and easier to shoot fast.
  • Capacity: a 9mm magazine holds more rounds than a .40 S&W magazine in the same size pistol.
  • Wear: the .40 S&W is harder on small pistols over time.

“Bigger bullet, more snap.”

Why so many moved to 9mm

Modern hollow point bullets changed the math. With good defensive loads, the performance gap between the two rounds got much smaller. The FBI moved back to 9mm in the last decade, and many police agencies followed, citing easier training, more rounds on board and less wear on guns.

“Good bullets closed most of the gap.”

Where the .40 S&W still makes sense

If you already own a .40 S&W pistol and shoot it well, there is no need to switch. Used .40 S&W pistols from police trade ins often show up at good prices. Some .40 S&W pistols can also be converted to 9mm with a barrel swap from the maker. Check before you buy parts.

What about cost per round?

For many shooters the deciding factor is the cost of practice. The chart at the top compares the two from live listings on Gun Search Engine. Federal .40 S&W puts one maker's loads side by side, and Smith & Wesson .40 S&W shows the brand that gave the round its name.

“Shoot both before you pick.”

Quick answers

  • Is .40 S&W more powerful than 9mm? It fires a heavier bullet, but with modern defensive loads the gap is small.
  • Can a 9mm pistol shoot .40 S&W? No. Never mix them.
  • Which is easier for a new shooter? Most find the 9mm easier to control.

Ready to compare? See .40 S&W handguns and 9mm handguns, or check .40 S&W ammo deals.

Where to shop

Shop the hubs

Browse live stock, or list inventory if you sell.

← All posts